Friday, February 13, 2009

Question

Blouse/jacket no. 102 of February BWOF is one of the projects I want to make. Reading the instructions, I saw that this jacket is the short version of dress no. 101. A bit strange, as the ease in a jacket is usually more than in a dress?

Probably jacket 102 is more the kind of jacket to be worn as a blouse, at least, that's how I would wear it. But in construction it's more described as a jacket, and lining is used for the jacket/blouse, but not for the dress.

If I were to make this jacket/blouse from a blouse quality linen, would you use lining? I usually don't line my blouses, but would I have to do it on this pattern?

Your ideas and thoughts are very  much appreciated.

15 comments:

  1. Gosh, good question. Don't have an answer for you, but I liked that jacket also, and am interested in what your other "commenters" have to say. I like a LOT of the things in this issue, maybe I'll finally justify my BWOF subscription!
    Off to re-check out your post about fabric manipulation (I think that's what you called it)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Took awhile, but I finally found it. You called it origami. I'm seeing alot of this lately(maybe we're behind the times here out west, or maybe I wasn't paying attention), and youngest dd recently bought a top with a similar technique recently. Thanks for the tutorial!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Sigrid,

    I'm planning on making this too, also in a navy blue linen. I was going to line it to cut down on wrinkling. Something light, like a batiste I think.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey Sigrid,
    I'd only line it for modesty's sake, (if it's see thru against sun), it has the belt, so I think they meant it to be halfway, partly jacket/blouse, silk organza might be nice one for the lining too, it prolly would make it look more like a jacket.... jsut thinking aloud...hm.. I've been wondering that ease thing too, they are doing these jacket/dress/blouse combo's every once in a while.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Good question. They do this sometimes, and my guess is the same that you'd wear it without a top under neath. I think that lining it would give it a more jacket feel Honestly, just do what you want. If it were a light color I think that a lining would make it more opaque.

    ReplyDelete
  6. How would you plan to finish the inside seams? It might be easier to line than seam finishing. I am not sure what I would do so will be interested to see which way you go.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I really like this jacket (or blouse!) pattern too. Personally I would line it because I find that easier than making all the seams neat on the inside on a jacket and I know I would wear it more as a jacket than a blouse. But either way will definitely work.

    ReplyDelete
  8. There is no doubt that I would line it in linen, particularly if it is 100% linen. I'd underline it, too, with fusible interfacing. My feeling is that if I didn't do these things, I'd end up looking like a wrinkly blog. My thoughts are based on linen fabric though. There would still be wrinkles, but I think it would still be better lined and underlined.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Clarification--I'd line the linen with a lining fabric. My post made it sound like I'd line it in the same fabric.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think this is completely up to you. Personally I would not line it in your case if you are going for more of a blouse-like appearance. I regularly inspect the interiors of designer RTW garments and linings are no longer mandatory, just a nice seam finish. Whatever you think is best. I am glad you are making this because I want to make it too.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This jacket/blouse looks designed for you!
    Personally, I wouldn't line it if I was using cotton (which would be my choice of fabric), but would probably line it if was planning on using linen, like you are.
    I know you will do a great job with this, and it will look great on you!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Wow, I love that pattern. Can you buy Burda WOF at the newstand, or d you have to subscribe?

    ReplyDelete
  13. I'm making this too with silk noil, and I'm lining it. I thought about skipping the lining, but I like the nice neat look on the inside that the lining gives.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hi Sigrid,
    Just thought I'd add my 5c worth! I really like both these garments and didn't realise they were from the same pattern. Bit of a surprise!
    The only thought I have is that recently I bought some gorgeous linen to make a Vogue dress, and asked in the dress shop if/what I should line it with. The lady suggested cotton batiste as this is very light and more breathable for a summer garment. I know some people wouldn't bother but I think it gives a nice finish.
    Tot siens!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Those are lovely jacket, which I could do BWOF.... How do you determine your size in BWOF magazine? I have never tried it before as I am beginner sewist.
    Bust- 39
    waist- 34
    hips 44.5.
    Thanks and have a lovely weekend

    ReplyDelete

It's always nice to have feedback on what I'm posting about. All comments, also positive criticism, are always highly appreciated.
Leuk als je een berichtje schrijft, altijd leuk om te lezen, ook opbouwende kritiek!